Menus
- Pickens
- Wings
- Grazins
- The Prairie
- Spuds
- The Pit
- The Coop
- Deli Delights
- South of Buffalo
- Not From Lake Erie
- Sweet Slices
- Belly Wash
- Party Menu
Pickens
-
Flowering Onion
A Colossal Sweet Vidalia onion lightly seasoned & flour-dusted, fried & served with our awesome horseradish sauce. Our customers say it is better than the Australian version. We fry with 100% canola oil.
$9.99
-
Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel
A huge oven-baked pretzel served with Wisconsin beer cheese. A great pairing with your favorite beer.
$10.99
-
Irish Nachos
Delicious kettle potato chips smothered in cheddar cheese, lotsa bacon and green onion. Served with delicious ranch dip
$8.99
Buffalo Chicken Style with Crumbled Blue Cheese add $3
-
Smoked Fish Dip
Our Mahi is smoked in-house and served Key West style with tortilla chips, capers, roasted red peppers, onion & jalapeño
$10.99
-
Fried Green Tomatoes
4 slices battered and fried with Memaw’s secret herbs & spices. Served with our delicious sweet horsey sauce.
$5.99
-
Beer-Battered Onion Rings
$6.99
-
Beer-Battered Mushrooms
$6.99
-
Fried Pickle Chips
$8.99
-
Jalapeno Poppers
6- cheddar stuffed fried til golden. Served with sweet-hot pepper jam.
$8.99
-
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.99
-
12" New York Style Pizza
Hand-tossed with marinara and mozzarella cheese - additional toppings $1.00 each - pepperoni, bacon, tomato, black olive, mushroom, green pepper, onion, extra cheese or jalapeño
$8.99
-
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$13.99
-
Pico De Gallo & Tortilla Chips
Our classic fresh chopped salsa with tomato, onion, jalapeño, cilantro and lime juice.
$7.99
-
Guacamole & Tortilla Chips
Homemade with fresh avocado, onion, tomato and lime.
$7.99
Authentic Buffalo Style - Large and fresh cooked to order. Never breaded or frozen. We use all natural ingredients in our award winning original sauce recipes made fresh daily, not from a jar or can, like our competitors. We refuse to skimp on size or quality; this is why we are known for serving the best chicken wings in the world.
Add Garlic to Any Flavor for 60¢
Specialty Sauces (*) Add 1.00 Per Order
Sides of Blue Cheese or Ranch Dressing 60¢ each
Celery Pack (5-6) 60¢ each
16oz Blue Cheese $6.00 each
160z Ranch Dressing $5.00 each
Size & Prices
-
5 Wings
$9
-
10 Wings
$16
-
15 Wings
$23
-
20 Wings
$30
-
30 Wings
$40
-
40 Wings
$50
-
50 Wings
$60
Sauces
-
Mild
-
Medium
-
Oriental
-
BBQ
-
Hot
-
Suicide
-
Zippy Cajun
-
Killer
-
Thai Chili*
-
Death*
-
Taco Salad
Loads of shredded lettuce topped with your choice of charbroiled chicken breast, pork, or 100% Angus taco beef. Served with sour cream, our homemade pico de gallo, black olives and guacamole. Served in tortilla bowl. Fresh jalapeño available!
$12.99
-
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Our huge house salad kicked up with Buffalo Chicken strips. Served with blue cheese. No sharing charge
$12.99
-
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled, marinated chicken breast over fresh romaine, croutons and parmesan cheese. Served with garlic bread and a side of caesar dressing. | Substitute fresh gulf grouper or maki-mahi (market price)
$12.99
-
House Salad
Large mixture of fresh greens, parmesan, tomatoes, cucumber, carrot and Sweet Vidalia onion. Your choice of dressing
$7.99
-
Gyro Greek Salad
Shaved Gyro Meat (Lamb and Beef) over Fresh Romaine, Cucumber, Onion, Tomato, Kalamata Olives, Chick Peas, Grape Leaves, Pepperoncini and Feta Cheese. Served with our amazing Greek Dressing and a side of Tzatziki Sauce.
$14.99
-
Bistro Steak Salad
Seared USDA Prime Tri-tip Sirloin Over Fresh Greens with Crumbled Blue Cheese, White Onion, Tomato, Cucumber, Carrot, Sweet Peppers, Crumbled Bacon, Avocado and Hard Boiled Egg. Served with our Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing.
$16.99
-
Side Salad
A smaller version of our house or Caesar salad.
$4
Add to Any Entrée $1.95
-
Side Coleslaw
Made fresh daily
$2.50
Stock Pot
-
Bowl of Hank’s Homemade Soup of the Day
$4.99
-
Bowl of Buffalo Chili
Made with real Buffalo
$6.99
-
Bowl of Loaded Buffalo Chili
Tortilla Chips, Onions, Cheese & Sour cream
$7.99
The Prairie
-
Black Angus Burger
½ pound of Charbroiled Certified Angus Beef . Simply the most delicious burger possible. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, & sliced garlic deli pickles on a fresh bun. Cheese, Bacon or other premium toppings are extra.
$8.99
-
Buffalo Burger
½ pound of nutritious 100% buffalo. Buffalo is lower in cholesterol than fish or chicken and has more protein than beef. We recommend cooking temperature of medium or less because it’s so lean! Served with lettuce, tomato, and sliced garlic deli pickles
$13.99
-
BBQ Pork Sandwich
Slowly smoked then shredded and smothered with our honey BBQ sauce. Served on a fresh bun with slaw or BBQ beans and pickle
$9.99
-
Beef on Weck Sandwich
Shaved Certified Angus Beef top round on a Costanzos hard roll with horseradish. If you are not from up-state New York area...this is best described as a really, really good roast beef sandwich.
$11.99
-
Meatloaf Dinner
Not your mother’s meatloaf! We use 100% Certified Angus Beef . Simply the best you will ever try. Kicked up with our original sauce. Served with 2 sides, available all day.
$12.99
-
Sahlen Hot Dog
Buffalo’s finest. Served with slaw or BBQ beans and pickle. Add cheese, chili or bacon for $1.50 each. Add a second dog for only $3.00
$6.99
Create Your Own Gourmet Burger
-
Choose Your Toppings
American Cheese $0.50
Swiss Cheese $1
Cheddar Cheese $1
Blue Cheese $1
Provolone $1
Grilled Onion $1
Grilled Mushroom $1
Grilled Jalapeño $1
Guacamole $1.50
Bacon $1.50
Pico de Gallo $1
Fried Egg $1
Pepper Jack Cheese $1
-
Handful of Straight Cut Fries With Any Order Add
$2.50
-
Handful of Curlies or Buffalo Chips Add
$3
-
Handful of Onion Rings Add
$3.50
Spuds
Our trademark Buffalo Chip French Fry is a natural thick-cut potato with the skin on... Really good dunked in Blue cheese dressing or ranch | Add Chili, Cheese or Gravy to any item for $2.00 | Cajun Seasoned Add $0.50-
Straight Cut Fries
Handful $2.50
Basket $3.99
-
Curly Fries
Handful $3
Basket $4.99
-
Buffalo Chips Fries
Handful $3
Basket $4.99
-
Kettle Chips
Handful $3
Basket $4.99
The Pit
-
Baby Back Ribs
Premium Danish smoked to perfection with our honey BBQ glaze. We already have the best wings in the world… Now we have the best ribs too! Served with 2 sides.
1/2 Rack $15.99
Full Rack $23.99
-
Beef Brisket Plate
Slow smoked and sliced thin with your choice of sweet, spicy or hot BBQ sauce. Served with 2 sides.
$13.99
-
Pulled Pork Plate
Slow–smoked with hickory & cherry wood. Top with your choice of sweet, spicy or hot BBQ sauce. Served with 2 sides.
$12.99
Sides
$1.50 upcharge for picking 2 from 1st side group. $1.00 upcharge for switching fries to curlies or chips. Add a side salad for $1.95-
Pick One
Fries | Baked Potato | Mashed Potato | Mac-n-Cheese | Potato Salad
-
Sides Pick Another
Green Beans | BBQ Baked Beans | Coleslaw | Corn Bread | Garlic Bread | Collard Greens | Cottage Cheese
-
Potato Salad
The Coop
-
Country Fried Chicken Dinner
A tenderized 8 oz. marinated breast of chicken rolled in Memaw’s secret flour recipe. Fried golden and smothered with country gravy. Served with 2 sides and corn bread. Our good ole’ boy favorite, available all day.
$12.99
-
Chip’s Chicken Tenders
Large portion of fried fresh tenders lightly breaded and shaken in your choice of one of our famous wing sauces. Served with celery and blue cheese. Ask for naked tenders and get your sauce on side for dippin’. Add Straight Cut Fries $2.50 - Add Curly or Buffalo Chips $3.00
$9.99
-
Fireballs
100% Chicken breast chunks, battered deep-fried and rolled in your choice of sauce. Served with celery & blue cheese.
$9.99
-
Chicken Philly Sub
Seasoned tenderloins grilled with green peppers, onion, mushroom and topped with melted provolone. Served on a Constanzo’s sub roll with our awesome horsey sauce.
$12.99
-
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Breaded & fried golden brown. Rolled in your favorite sauce. Served with blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and choice of slaw or beans.
$12.99
-
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Marinated and Grilled breast. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, coleslaw and pickle. Good lower calorie choice for those weight watchers
$11.99
Deli Delights
-
The Reuben Sandwich
Grilled Rye stuffed with our in-house made corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss. 1000 island on the side. Oy Vey! A best-seller. Substitute Turkey?...No problem. Includes choice of coleslaw or BBQ baked beans.
$12.99
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Fried Buffalo Style Chicken rolled up with lettuce, tomato and onion. Your choice of blue cheese or ranch. Served with pickle and choice of coleslaw or BBQ baked beans. Hold the wing sauce - Or ask for it on the side is O.K. with us!
$12.99
-
Turkey Club Wrap
All-natural turkey wrapped with bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato and avocado served with a side of homemade Ranch. Includes choice of coleslaw or BBQ baked beans.
$12.99
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Fried Chicken Tenders wrapped with fresh romaine and parmesan. Served with a side of our Caesar dressing and includes choice of coleslaw or BBQ baked beans.
$12.99
South of Buffalo
-
Fish Tacos
Filled with your choice of fried Haddock or blackened Mahi-Mahi topped with lettuce, avocado & pico de gallo. Served with our awesome roasted tomatilla verde salsa on the side
$12.99
-
Enchiladas Diablo
2 tortillas rolled with your choice of chili verde smoked pork, seasoned ground beef or chicken smothered with cheddar-jack cheese and Debbie’s delicious Diablo sauce. Served with lettuce & pico de gallo
$12.99
-
Chicken Quesadilla
A grilled giant flour tortilla stuffed with blended cheeses and chicken. Served with pico de gallo and sour cream
$11.99
-
Diablo Pork Nachos
Layers of tortilla chips, house smoked shredded pork, our homemade Diablo sauce and lots of mozzarella cheese. Topped with shredded lettuce and pico-de-gallo with a side of sour cream. Don't let the name scare you, they're not overly spicy!
$13.99
Not From Lake Erie
-
Buffalo Shrimp
6 big lightly breaded fried shrimp shaken up with your favorite sauce. Or ask for naked with your choice of sauce on the side. Served with celery and blue cheese
$9.99
-
Haddock Fish Sandwich
Our Huge flaky white haddock beer-battered or lightly dusted. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, slaw and pickle
$11.99
-
Grouper Sandwich
100% fresh Gulf Grouper. The real thing. ½ lb. grilled, blackened, beer–battered or lightly dusted. Served with lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion and tartar sauce on the side. **Available as Grouper Bites Appitizer as well for $17.99**or Available as a Grouper Dinner with 2 sides for $21.99**
$19.99
-
Fish & Chips
If you can’t make up your mind, just order this. It’s our beerbattered ½ lb. of Haddock sliced into fingers and accompanied by our famous Buffalo Chips potatoes - thick cut skin-on chips. Served with tartar sauce and lemon. You can’t go wrong –just like the ole’ Buffalo Friday fish fry.
$13.99
Sweet Slices
-
Chocolate Cake
$7.99
-
Key Lime Pie
$5.99
-
Apple Walnut Bread Pudding
Homemade *Contains Nuts
$5.99
Soft Drinks
$2.25 Each - One Free Refill-
Pepsi
-
Diet Pepsi
-
Orange Crush
-
Dr. Pepper
-
Starry
-
Mountain Dew
-
Lemonade
-
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Unsweetened or Sweet
-
Bottle of IBC Rootbeer
$3
-
Coffee
$2.50
-
Milk
$2.50
BOTTLED BEER
-
Budweiser
-
Bud Light
-
Miller Lite
-
Coors Light
-
Corona
-
Corona Light
-
Michelob Ultra
-
Michelob Amber Bock
-
Modelo Especial
-
Heineken
-
Heineken 0.0
Non Alcoholic
-
O'Douls
Non Alcoholic
DRAFT BEER
-
Bud Light
-
Michelob Ultra
-
Stella Artois
-
Coors Light
-
Labatt Blue
-
Modelo Especial
-
Miller Lite
-
Yuengling
-
Blue Moon
-
Fort Myers Brewing - High 5 IPA
Wine
-
Woodbridge House Wines
6oz Glass - $4.50
Red Blend
Pinot Grigio
Chardonnay
-
Cavit Pinot Grigio
375ML Mini Bottle
$12
-
Kendal Jackson Chardonnay
375ML Mini Bottle
$12
-
Josh Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon
375ML Mini Bottle
$12
-
Freixenet Cordon Negro Brut
Sparkling - Split
$7
Margaritas & Sangrias
-
Sabé Lime & Agave Margarita
Over Ice with a Salted Rim
$8
-
*NEW* Red Sangria
$5
Hard Seltzer & Cider
-
White Claw Hard Seltzer
Raspberry - Black Cherry
$4
-
High Noon Hard Seltzer
Pineapple - Peach - Watermelon
$4
-
Angry Orchard Hard Cider
Crisp Apple
$4
Wings
-
50 World Famous Buffalo Wings
$60
Grazins/Salads
-
House Salad - Feeds 8-10 people -- Requires 24 hour notice
$50
-
Caesar Salad -- Feeds 8-10 people -- Requires 24 hour notice
$60
-
Buffalo Chicken Salad -- Feeds 8-10 people -- Requires 24 hour notice
$80
Spuds
-
Straight Cut Fries -- Basket size only
$3.99
-
Cajun Curly Fries -- Basket size only
$4.99
-
Buffalo Chip Fries -- Basket size only
$4.99
The Pit/BBQ Meats
-
1 Slab Baby Back Ribs -- Requires 24 hour notice
$18
-
1 lb. Brisket -- Requires 24 hour notice
$16
-
1 lb. of Pork -- Requires 24 hour notice
$15
The Coop
-
1 lb. of Chicken Tenders
$15
Veggie Platter
-
Veggie Platter -- Requires 24 hour notice
$20
Sides
-
Coleslaw -- Requires 24 hour notice
$12
-
Mac & Cheese -- Requires 24 hour notice
$15
-
BBQ Beans -- Requires 24 hour notice
$15
-
Cornbread --64 pieces -- Requires 24 hour notice
$22
-
Chili -- Feeds 10 people -- Requires 24 hour notice
$60
Plates & Utensils
-
Plates & Utensils -- price is per person
$0.50